Another Round of Picture Critique

Munchow_1659-047_E1

It’s been a long time since I have been available for picture critique. I think it’s time for another round again! So once again, I open up for submission of photos anyone would like some feedback on. This is the third time I do this and the previous rounds were well received by those who sent me their photos. If you want to see the photos I previously critiqued you will find an overview in my posts First Session of Picture Critique and A Good Round of Picture Critiquing.

For a long time I have wanted to start a new picture critique session, but life has been too busy the last year or so to be able to make it happen. It’s definitely about time to get going again. As last time my idea is to let any of you who have pictures you want to have some feedback on to post them on my page Picture Critique. This could be a picture you are unsure about, a picture that is different from your usual style or just a picture that you want know how to do better. Go to the Picture Critique page, post a link to the picture and I will soon give my honest view and perception of your picture in what I attempt to be constructive and meaningful critique.

I both teach and attend a lot of workshops, and one of the greatest values from participating in photographic workshops is the possibility to have feedback on pictures you take. I know from the workshops I teach that this is what students appreciate the most. Therefore, here is a chance to get feedback on your pictures without having to participate in an expensive workshop. Not quite the same of course, but I hope it can be of some value.

If you are interested, go to the Picture Critique page to read more or just post a picture there. I hope to see your picture soon. Please do not post any picture or links to pictures here, but go to the Picture Critique page.

First Session of Picture Critique


Thanks all of you who have submitted pictures to my picture critique page and taken a chance by letting me pass on my opinion about the pictures. I hope I haven’t been too critical.

To sum up the experience of the first sessions of picture critique that I started last week, I can say, for myself at least, that it’s been quite an interesting process. It’s been fun to see the variety of pictures submitted to this informal review of other photographs’ work. The level has been good, which makes it easier for me to make some commendable comments – and maybe push the stakes a little more, too.

As I say in a summarizing comment on the page: The fact is I think all the pictures are good works by talented photographers, but the better the pictures are, the more critical I become. Otherwise I don’t see any point of this exercise. If you want to stretch yourself you need something to stretch for. This said, I am also fully aware that the views presented are only my opinions. There is no absolute right or wrong, and somebody else might see the pictures totally different. With this in mind I think the most important thing for any picture critique is pointing out what is good or bad. It’s too easy to say «I like» or just push the button. But if we want to learn something we need to know why and we need to be able to express why we like or don’t like a picture.

One thing most of the submitted picture had in common – as far I see it – is a lack of intent. I feel a majority of the photographers hadn’t been quite clear about why they took the pictures they did and what they wanted to say with them. That’s actually why I wrote the post about photographic vision and intent earlier this week. If you haven’t read it, please take a look, because for me the intention behind a photograph is what makes it stand out and makes it become interesting for others.

Unfortunately the technical part of downloading the pictures to the critique page didn’t work out as smoothly as I had hoped. The code I submitted on the page didn’t work for anybody else than me. WordPress has obviously closed the possibilities for others to post pictures in a comment. If anyone knows how to get around this limitation, I would really appreciate if you let me know. I will now close this first session of picture critique, simply to rethink the whole concept. If you have thoughts about how it can work more smoothly, please be so kind to let me know. I will let the page be open until the end of the weekend coming up. Sunday evening will in other words be the last chance to submit any pictures. After that I will close it for further posting. But don’t worry, if you would like to have a picture critiqued and don’t make it by the end of the weekend. I will soon open up a new session – and hopefully it will all be working more smoothly.

If you want to use the opportunity to have your picture critiqued, post a link to where I can find it on the Picture Critique page.

Post a Picture and Get Feedback


Today I have just added a new feature to this blog. It’s the page called Picture Critique. My idea is to open up for any of you who have pictures you want to have some feedback on. This could be pictures you are unsure about, pictures that are different from your usual style or just pictures that you what know how to do better. Go to the page and post the picture and I will soon give my honest view and perception of your picture in what I attempt to be constructive and meaningful critique.

One of the greatest values from participating in photographic workshops is the possibility to have feedback on pictures you take. I know from the many workshops I teach that this is what the students appreciate most of. So here is a chance to get feed back on your pictures without having to participate in an expensive workshop.

Go here to read more or post a picture. I hope to see your picture soon.